
Going ALL IN: Why Mental Performance Training is the Game-Changer for Athletes Moving from High School to College
By Dr. Heather D. Larkin, LMHC, MGCP, MPM
Mental Health & Mental Performance Specialist
Making the leap from high school to college sports is one of the most challenging transitions an athlete will face—and that’s where mental performance training for college athletes becomes a true game-changer. The physical grind is obvious, but what separates those who thrive from those who struggle isn’t just talent or work ethic—it’s mental performance. And at the heart of that success lies developing the ALL IN Mindset™, built on five key pillars: Awareness, Let Go, Lock In, Intrinsic Confidence, and Next Play Mentality.
Awareness: The First Step to Thriving Under Pressure
The moment a high school athlete steps onto a college campus, the game changes. New teammates, faster competition, and higher expectations can create mental overload. Awareness is the ability to recognize what’s happening internally and externally without judgment. Research shows that athletes who practice self-awareness are 23% more likely to adapt successfully to high-pressure environments. For a freshman quarterback noticing his heart rate spike before his first college game, awareness isn’t about “fixing” the nerves; it’s about acknowledging, “I’m anxious because this matters,” and using that energy to prepare instead of panic. Awareness becomes the compass in the chaos, allowing athletes to stay grounded no matter how intense the storm.
Let Go of Limitations: Releasing the Weight That Holds You Back
One of the biggest hurdles athletes face during this transition is carrying the weight of mistakes or expectations. The fear of failing a test, missing a shot, or disappointing a coach can create mental clutter that destroys performance. Letting go isn’t about forgetting—it’s about releasing what you can’t control to make space for what you can. College athletes who master this skill report lower levels of performance anxiety and burnout. Imagine a soccer player who misses a penalty kick in her first conference game. Without the ability to let go, that moment follows her into every practice and class. With mental performance training, she learns to take the lesson, drop the baggage, and step back on the field free from the chains of one mistake.
Lock In: Mastering Focus in a World Full of Distractions
Balancing academics, sports, and social life in college is like spinning three plates while running a sprint. Locking in is the art of directing all your energy to the present moment. It’s what allows a pitcher to tune out the roar of a packed stadium and hit his target or a student-athlete to fully engage in a lecture after a grueling morning workout. Studies on
NCAA athletes show that those with strong mental focus perform 21% better under stress compared to peers without mental training. The ALL IN Mindset™ teaches athletes to create routines—breathing exercises, trigger words, or mental cues—that act as an “on switch” to get laser-focused on the task at hand, whether it’s a championship game or a chemistry exam.
Intrinsic Confidence: Trusting Yourself at the Next Level
One of the most common struggles for new college athletes is self-doubt. Going from being the star in high school to being surrounded by equally talented or more skilled athletes can shake even the strongest egos. Intrinsic confidence isn’t about hype or external validation—it’s a deep trust in your preparation and abilities that doesn’t waver when the scoreboard isn’t in your favor. Mental performance training rewires negative self-talk into powerful internal dialogue. Picture a freshman basketball player like Trey Jefferson, who starts the season missing more shots than he makes. Without intrinsic confidence, he spirals into “Maybe I’m not good enough.” With it, he says, “I’m prepared. My shot will fall. Keep working.” That belief becomes the difference between athletes who break and athletes who break through.
Next Play Mentality: Turning Setbacks into Fuel
College sports and academics are filled with highs and lows. A failed exam, a tough loss, or a bad practice can feel devastating without the right mindset. The Next Play Mentality is the ability to quickly shift focus from what just happened to what’s next. It’s the skill that separates champions from everyone else. Research on elite performers shows that those who can mentally reset within 30 seconds of a mistake maintain up to 40% higher consistency under pressure. For Trey, who once let one turnover ruin an entire half, learning the Next Play Mentality changed everything. After a costly error in the conference finals, he used his mental cue “Catch it. Reset. Next Play.”, to regroup and make the game-winning assist just two possessions later.
The ALL IN Mindset™: A Blueprint for College Success
The transition to college is a test of more than physical skill. It’s a test of mental endurance, adaptability, and balance. Athletes who develop the ALL IN Mindset™: Awareness, Let Go, Lock In, Intrinsic Confidence, and Next Play Mentality—aren’t just equipped to handle the pressure; they’re primed to excel academically, athletically, and personally.
College athletics demand more than talent! It demands total commitment of mind and body. By investing in mental performance training, athletes can turn one of the most challenging transitions of their lives into the foundation for lifelong success. Whether you’re a student-athlete about to make the leap or a parent supporting one, the message is
clear: developing an ALL IN Mindset™ isn’t optional. It’s the competitive edge that turns potential into peak performance, on and off the field.
Dr. Heather Larkin, LMHC, MGCP, MPM
ALL IN Counseling & Mental Performance Coaching
617.807.0667